During a busy shift, a care worker accidentally administers the wrong medication to a patient. While the mistake is noticed quickly, the impact could have been severe. The Duty of Care is what guides care workers to prevent these types of incidents, ensuring that safety is maintained at all times. However, when an error does occur, the Duty of Candour comes into play. It requires care workers to be honest, transparent, and open about the situation, providing clear information and offering apologies.
The relationship between Duty of Care and Duty of Candour is crucial in maintaining safety, trust, and accountability in care environments. Duty of Care focuses on preventing harm and providing safe, competent care. On the other hand, Duty of Candour ensures that when things go wrong, transparency is prioritised, and mistakes are handled appropriately.
In this guide, we’ll break down the link between Duty of Care and Duty of Candour, showing you how these responsibilities protect both the care provider and the individual receiving care. We’ll also provide practical examples, explain the legal frameworks, and outline how these duties must be applied in real care settings.
TL;DR
- Duty of Care focuses on preventing harm and ensuring safe care.
- Duty of Candour requires openness and honesty when something goes wrong in care.
- Duty of Care is proactive (preventing harm), while Duty of Candour is reactive (responding to harm).
- Duty of Candour applies when there is a notifiable safety incident or harm caused to the patient.
- Both duties work together to build trust between care providers and patients.
- Duty of Care supports patient safety, and Duty of Candour ensures transparency after an incident.
- The Duty of Candour mandates apologising, providing explanations, and offering support to affected individuals.
- Failure to comply with Duty of Candour can lead to regulatory actions and loss of trust.
Health and Social Care Level 3 Diploma
Authority Clarification Section
When discussing the Duty of Care and Duty of Candour, it’s crucial to distinguish between the legal requirements and professional obligations that guide healthcare providers.
CQC Regulation 20: Duty of Candour
Under Regulation 20 of the Health and Social Care Act 2008 (Regulated Activities) Regulations 2014, the Care Quality Commission (CQC) mandates that healthcare providers must be open, honest, and transparent when something goes wrong in the care process. This statutory duty ensures that if a notifiable safety incident occurs, the patient or their family is informed, an apology is offered, and corrective actions are taken to prevent future incidents.
GMC/NMC Professional Duties
In addition to the CQC’s statutory requirements, healthcare professionals are governed by their respective professional bodies, such as the General Medical Council (GMC) for doctors and the Nursing and Midwifery Council (NMC) for nurses. These bodies enforce professional duties that require members to be open and honest with patients when incidents occur. While GMC/NMC guidelines align with the Duty of Candour, they focus on professional ethics rather than legal enforcement.
Law vs. Guidance
- Law: Regulation 20 establishes a legal obligation for healthcare providers to act transparently when harm occurs, with specific guidelines for how to address notifiable incidents.
- Guidance: The GMC/NMC professional duties guide healthcare workers on ethical transparency. While these professional standards are not legally binding, they ensure healthcare professionals maintain honesty and integrity when dealing with patients and incidents.
What Is the Relationship Between Duty of Care and Duty of Candour?
The Duty of Care and Duty of Candour are two fundamental responsibilities that guide care workers in providing safe, ethical care. While both duties focus on ensuring the well-being of individuals receiving care, they serve different purposes and operate at different stages in the care process.
Duty of Care: Preventing Harm
The Duty of Care is proactive. Its primary goal is to prevent harm before it happens. This duty requires care workers to take reasonable steps to ensure that individuals are safe, protected from abuse, and supported in their physical and emotional needs.
For example, ensuring that a patient receives the correct medication, monitoring risks like falls, and maintaining a clean and safe environment are all part of fulfilling the Duty of Care.
Duty of Candour: Responding to Harm
On the other hand, the Duty of Candour is reactive. It comes into play after harm or an error occurs, particularly when a notifiable safety incident takes place. Duty of Candour ensures that care workers are honest, open, and transparent when things go wrong.
This includes informing the affected individual, offering a sincere apology, explaining the situation, and outlining the steps taken to prevent the issue from happening again.
Key Differences
Duty of Care | Duty of Candour |
Proactive: Aims to prevent harm | Reactive: Ensures transparency after an incident occurs |
Focuses on safe practices and risk management | Focuses on honesty and openness with those affected |
Prevents harm through actions, safety checks, and procedures | Requires communication and accountability after the harm |
How They Work Together
Both duties are linked but distinct. The Duty of Care helps prevent incidents that might lead to harm, while the Duty of Candour steps in when something goes wrong. By working together, these duties create a care system based on safety, trust, and accountability.
They ensure that individuals are not only protected but also that they are treated with respect and honesty when things don’t go as planned.
What Is Duty of Care in Health and Social Care?
The Duty of Care in health and social care is the legal, ethical, and moral obligation of care workers to provide safe, competent, and effective care to individuals. It ensures that care workers take reasonable steps to prevent foreseeable harm, maintain the well-being of those they support, and uphold their dignity and rights.
Legal Grounding
The Duty of Care originates from common law, meaning it is rooted in the legal principles of negligence. This duty requires care workers to act reasonably in preventing harm to the individuals in their care. If a care worker fails in their duty, and this leads to harm, they may be held legally accountable.
Practical Meaning for Care Workers
In everyday practice, Duty of Care translates into actions that prevent harm and safeguard individuals’ rights. This includes maintaining a safe environment, providing the correct level of care, and acting responsibly when faced with potential risks.
Examples
- Medication administration: Ensuring the correct dosage is given and confirming the patient’s medical history to avoid harm.
- Fall prevention: Checking that the environment is free from hazards, like loose rugs or wet floors, to avoid falls.
- Reporting hazards: Identifying and reporting any risks, such as faulty equipment, to prevent accidents or injuries.
What Is Duty of Candour?
Duty of Candour is the legal requirement for healthcare providers and professionals to be open, honest, and transparent when something goes wrong in care that causes, or has the potential to cause, harm or distress to a patient.
This duty ensures that the affected individual, their family, or their advocate is informed about the incident and receives a sincere apology, as well as information about the steps being taken to prevent a similar incident in the future.
Statutory vs. Professional Duty of Candour
There are two types of Duty of Candour:
Statutory Duty
This duty is legally binding under CQC Regulation 20 (Health and Social Care Act 2008). It applies to all care providers registered with the Care Quality Commission (CQC) and sets clear requirements for notifiable safety incidents.
Professional Duty
This is the responsibility for individual healthcare professionals (e.g., doctors, nurses) to be transparent with patients and their families. It’s regulated by professional bodies like the General Medical Council (GMC) and Nursing and Midwifery Council (NMC).
Key Elements of Duty of Candour
- Apology: A sincere apology for the harm caused, acknowledging the distress or injury without admitting liability.
- Clear Communication: Providers must explain what happened, the impact on the patient, and the steps taken to prevent recurrence.
- Investigation: An appropriate investigation must follow the incident to identify the root cause and make improvements.
Is Duty of Candour Part of Duty of Care?
No, Duty of Candour is not part of Duty of Care, although they are closely related. The Duty of Care is proactive, focusing on preventing harm and ensuring safe, competent care. It requires care workers to take steps to avoid incidents before they happen, such as following protocols, conducting risk assessments, and making safe decisions in day-to-day care.
On the other hand, Duty of Candour is reactive. It comes into play only after an incident occurs that causes harm or distress. Duty of Candour ensures that when things go wrong, care providers are open, honest, and transparent about the mistake, explaining what happened, apologising, and offering support to the affected person.
In essence, Duty of Care is about avoiding harm, while Duty of Candour is about being honest and transparent when harm does occur. They work together, but they are distinct duties with different functions in the care process.
What Happens When Duty of Care Is Not Met?
When the Duty of Care is not met and harm occurs, the Duty of Candour steps in to ensure transparency and accountability. However, not every failure in care automatically triggers the Duty of Candour. The concept of a trigger point is important here: notifiable safety incidents are the specific situations where Duty of Candour applies.
When Duty of Candour Applies
A notifiable safety incident occurs when there is unintended harm or potential harm during the provision of care. These incidents could result in physical injury, psychological distress, or even death. Not all errors or lapses in care require Duty of Candour, but when the harm is significant or could have serious consequences, Duty of Candour mandates full disclosure.
For example:
- A patient falls due to improper safety measures and suffers a broken bone.
- Medication is administered incorrectly, causing a noticeable side effect.
In both cases, Duty of Candour applies because these are notifiable incidents that need to be communicated openly with the patient and their family.
What Professionals Must Do
When a notifiable safety incident occurs, professionals must take the following actions to meet their Duty of Candour responsibilities:
Inform the patient or family
Provide them with a clear explanation of what happened and how it affects them.
Apologise sincerely
Offer a genuine apology for the harm caused without admitting liability, acknowledging the distress it may have caused.
Offer support
Provide practical support, whether through follow-up care, counselling, or additional treatment.
Document the incident
Record the incident in the care records and ensure that all steps taken are logged appropriately.
Investigate and take corrective action
Ensure that the incident is reviewed, the causes are identified, and steps are taken to prevent recurrence.
Real-Life Examples of Duty of Care and Duty of Candour Working Together
The Duty of Care and Duty of Candour often work hand-in-hand in real care situations, with Duty of Care focused on preventing harm and Duty of Candour ensuring transparency when things go wrong. Below are examples showing how these two duties operate together:
Scenario 1: Medication Error
- Duty of Care: A care worker administers medication to a patient, but they mistakenly give the wrong dose. The worker immediately notices the error and closely monitors the patient for any signs of adverse reactions.
- Duty of Candour: The care worker informs the patient about the mistake, apologises for the error, and explains the potential effects of the incorrect medication. They also ensure the family is notified, and a formal investigation is initiated to prevent future errors. The incident is fully documented, and the care team discusses additional training to avoid similar mistakes.
Scenario 2: Patient Fall
- Duty of Care: During a shift, a care worker fails to secure a patient’s bed rails, resulting in a fall. The patient is injured but is promptly attended to by medical staff.
- Duty of Candour: The care worker immediately informs the patient about the fall and provides an honest explanation. A detailed apology is given, and the patient’s family is notified about the incident. A full investigation is conducted, and the care facility reviews its procedures to ensure bed rails are consistently checked and secured. The incident is recorded and used to implement further staff training on fall prevention.
Scenario 3: Communication Mistake
- Duty of Care: A nurse fails to pass along important patient information during a shift handover, resulting in a delay in the patient’s treatment. The error is noticed later when the patient’s condition worsens.
- Duty of Candour: The nurse communicates openly with the patient, explaining the mistake and offering a heartfelt apology for the delay in treatment. The patient’s family is also informed, and the nurse documents the incident. The healthcare team conducts a review to improve handover processes, ensuring clearer communication between shifts.
In each of these examples, Duty of Care works to prevent the harm, while Duty of Candour ensures that, when mistakes or incidents occur, the care provider is open, honest, and accountable. Together, these duties promote safety, trust, and continuous improvement in healthcare settings.
What Is the Difference Between Duty of Care and Duty of Candour?
While Duty of Care and Duty of Candour are both essential for ensuring high standards of care, they are distinct responsibilities with different purposes, timing, and legal foundations.
What Does the Law Say About Duty of Candour in the UK?
In the UK, Duty of Candour is a legal requirement under Regulation 20 of the Health and Social Care Act 2008 (Regulated Activities) Regulations 2014. This regulation applies to all care providers registered with the Care Quality Commission (CQC) and mandates that they be open and honest when something goes wrong during care that causes harm or has the potential to cause harm.
The statutory Duty of Candour requires healthcare providers to inform patients or their families about incidents, offer a genuine apology, and explain the situation in detail. They must also offer support and outline steps taken to prevent recurrence. This duty is enforced by the CQC, which monitors compliance during inspections.
Additionally, individual healthcare professionals have their own professional Duty of Candour. Bodies like the General Medical Council (GMC) and Nursing and Midwifery Council (NMC) regulate this responsibility for doctors and nurses. While the statutory Duty of Candour applies to all regulated providers, professional duties are specific to healthcare professionals and set by their respective regulatory bodies.
In England, the legal framework is clear, but similar principles apply across the UK, with slight variations in the regulatory bodies’ oversight and enforcement. The duty emphasises transparency, trust, and continuous learning from incidents, ensuring patients and their families are treated with respect and dignity.
Why Are Duty of Care and Duty of Candour Important in Practice?
Both Duty of Care and Duty of Candour are vital in fostering a safe, trustworthy, and accountable healthcare environment. These duties not only protect patients but also contribute to a culture of continuous improvement within healthcare settings.
Patient Safety
Duty of Care ensures that care workers actively prevent harm by managing risks and providing safe, competent care. When things go wrong, Duty of Candour ensures that the situation is addressed with honesty and transparency, making sure the patient and their family are informed and supported.
Trust and Accountability
Being open about errors through Duty of Candour builds trust with patients and families, showing that the care provider is committed to honesty and transparency. This accountability is crucial for maintaining professional integrity.
Continuous Improvement
Both duties promote learning from incidents. When harm occurs, Duty of Candour helps the team understand what went wrong and implement changes to avoid future mistakes. This process drives quality improvement, ensuring better care outcomes.
Together, these duties create a culture where safety, trust, and accountability are prioritised, leading to improved care quality and stronger relationships between care providers and service users.
Common Mistakes and Misunderstandings
There are several misconceptions about Duty of Care and Duty of Candour that can lead to confusion in practice:
- Apology ≠ Liability: Apologising for an incident does not mean admitting fault or accepting liability. It’s about acknowledging the impact and showing empathy.
- Candour ≠ Only Negligence: Duty of Candour applies not only when negligence occurs but also when any harm or significant incident happens, even if it wasn’t caused by negligence.
- Duties Are Not Interchangeable: While both duties aim to protect patients, Duty of Care prevents harm proactively, while Duty of Candour addresses harm after it occurs. They are distinct duties, not interchangeable.
How Should Care Workers Apply These Duties in Daily Practice?
Applying Duty of Care and Duty of Candour in daily practice requires care workers to follow clear steps to ensure patient safety, transparency, and accountability. Here’s how to implement both duties in real situations:
Preventing Harm – Duty of Care
- Identify Risks: Conduct regular risk assessments to identify potential hazards, whether in patient environments or during specific care activities.
- Provide Safe Care: Follow best practices and care protocols to prevent harm. Ensure safe medication administration, check equipment regularly, and maintain a clean, hazard-free environment.
- Report Concerns: If you spot any risks (e.g., faulty equipment, unsafe practices), report them immediately to prevent harm. Document all concerns and actions taken.
Responding to Incidents – Duty of Candour
- Inform the Patient/Family: If an incident occurs (e.g., medication error, fall), inform the patient or their family as soon as possible. Be honest about what happened and provide clear details.
- Apologise Sincerely: Offer a genuine apology. Acknowledge the harm caused without admitting fault, as the goal is to show empathy and transparency.
- Document the Incident: Accurately record the incident in the patient’s care plan. Include the sequence of events, actions taken, and any follow-up procedures.
- Report to Supervisors: Inform the appropriate healthcare team members and follow up with the necessary authorities or regulatory bodies (e.g., CQC, GMC, NMC) as required.
Learning and Improving
- Participate in Reviews: Take part in team discussions or investigations to understand what went wrong and how to prevent future incidents.
- Adjust Practices: Based on incident reviews, adjust care routines, training, or policies to ensure similar mistakes do not happen again.
- Foster a Culture of Openness: Encourage a team environment where staff feel comfortable reporting incidents and learning from them without fear of blame.
Practical Application Section
In daily healthcare practice, both Duty of Care and Duty of Candour play essential roles in ensuring safety, transparency, and quality care. Below is a practical guide on how care workers should apply these duties in real situations:
Applying Duty of Care
- Identify and Manage Risks: Regularly conduct risk assessments to identify potential hazards, whether in patient environments or during care activities. For example, ensuring that medical equipment is functioning correctly or preventing slips and falls in the care area.
- Ensure Competence: Always provide care according to best practices and professional standards. If you’re unsure about a procedure, seek guidance or additional training.
- Prevent Harm: If you notice any unsafe practice or risk (e.g., a patient’s mobility aid is damaged), report it immediately, take corrective actions, and ensure the patient’s safety.
- Respect Rights and Autonomy: Always consider the individual’s preferences and choices, and ensure they are informed to make decisions regarding their care.
Applying Duty of Candour
- Transparency After an Incident: If an incident occurs (e.g., medication error, fall), be transparent with the patient and their family. Acknowledge what happened, offer a clear explanation, and provide details of the corrective measures being taken.
- Offer a Sincere Apology: Apologise for the harm caused, focusing on the distress the patient or their family may have experienced. Avoid admitting liability but ensure the apology is sincere and shows empathy.
- Report and Document: Inform your manager or supervisor about the incident and document all relevant details. Accurate documentation is essential for transparency and continuity of care. It also ensures that the event is logged in accordance with regulations, should further action be required.
- Provide Support: Follow up with the patient and their family, offering emotional support and keeping them informed about the steps being taken to prevent future occurrences. This shows that you’re committed to learning from mistakes and improving care.
Summary & Key Takeaways for Learners and Practitioners
- Duty of Care ensures that care providers prevent harm by delivering safe, competent, and professional care.
- Duty of Candour mandates transparency and openness after harm occurs, ensuring patients and families are informed.
- The two duties are distinct but interconnected, with Duty of Care focusing on prevention, and Duty of Candour addressing response and accountability.
- Both duties are crucial in maintaining trust and ensuring accountability within healthcare settings.
- The CQC, GMC, and NMC regulate these duties, reinforcing their importance in patient safety and professional practice.
- Regular communication, documentation, and follow-up actions are essential in meeting both duties.
- Practitioners should always adhere to these duties to foster a safe, transparent, and ethical healthcare environment.
Health and Social Care Level 3 Diploma
FAQ
Q: What is duty of care?
A: Duty of care refers to the legal and ethical responsibility to ensure the safety, well-being, and rights of those receiving care, and to take reasonable steps to prevent harm.
Q: What is duty of candour?
A: Duty of candour is the legal obligation for healthcare providers to be open, honest, and transparent when things go wrong in care, offering apologies and clear explanations to those affected.
Q: How do they relate?
A: Duty of care aims to prevent harm by providing safe care, while duty of candour ensures transparency and accountability when harm or an incident occurs.
Q: Is duty of candour a legal requirement?
A: Yes, duty of candour is a legal requirement under Regulation 20 of the Health and Social Care Act 2008, enforced by the Care Quality Commission (CQC).
Q: When does duty of candour apply?
A: Duty of candour applies when a notifiable safety incident occurs that results in, or has the potential to cause, harm or distress to a patient or service user.
Q: Is duty of candour part of duty of care?
A: No, duty of candour is not part of duty of care. While duty of care focuses on preventing harm, duty of candour addresses the aftermath of incidents by ensuring openness and transparency.
Q: What is a notifiable safety incident?
A: A notifiable safety incident is any incident during care that results in or could result in serious harm or death. This requires the application of duty of candour.
Q: What happens if duty of candour is not followed?
A: Failing to follow duty of candour can lead to regulatory action from bodies like the CQC and can impact the provider’s reputation and credibility. It could also result in legal consequences.
Q: Do all mistakes require duty of candour?
A: No, not all mistakes trigger duty of candour. It only applies to notifiable safety incidents that cause, or have the potential to cause, harm or distress.
Q: Does apologising mean admitting fault?
A: No, apologising does not equate to admitting fault. An apology is about showing empathy and acknowledging the impact on the patient, not accepting legal liability.
Q: Who does duty of candour apply to?
A: Duty of candour applies to all health and social care providers, including individuals and organisations registered with regulatory bodies like the CQC. It also applies to healthcare professionals like doctors, nurses, and others regulated by bodies like the GMC or NMC.
Q: What is the professional duty of candour?
A: The professional duty of candour requires healthcare professionals to be open and transparent about mistakes, ensuring they act ethically and inform the patient and family appropriately. It is regulated by professional bodies such as the GMC and NMC.
Q: How does this affect care workers?
A: Care workers must adhere to both duty of care and duty of candour by ensuring safety in care delivery and being transparent and honest when errors occur. This builds trust with patients and improves care quality.
Q: Why is transparency important in care?
A: Transparency helps build trust, ensures accountability, and improves patient outcomes. It encourages learning from incidents and fosters a safer, more honest care environment.
Q: What is the difference between candour and complaints?
A: Candour refers to the open and honest communication about an incident that causes harm, while complaints are formal expressions of dissatisfaction from patients or families regarding care provided. Candour focuses on transparency in addressing incidents, while complaints typically seek resolution or compensation.





